Can a paper be rejected after minor revision?
When a paper of mine was first reviewed, one of the reviewers was okay with the paper and the other one requested minor revisions. The journal clearly said that the paper was accepted, subject to minor amendments and even went on to mention tentative publication dates. Now the journal has rejected the paper.
What is minor revision?
Loading when this answer was accepted… Minor revision usually implies that the reviewers (and the editor) think that authors can correct the paper in a way that will address all of the concerns, and the reviewers not need to see the paper again before publication.
What is substantial revision?
What is substantial revision? Substantial revision means that you not only re-wrote something, but had to “re-think” it. Most dramatically, you may have realized that you wanted to write about a different topic. Then you’d have to re-think the whole paper.
What is the objective of revision?
Revising gives students an opportunity to reflect on what they’ve written. Revising is a way to learn about the craft of writing. Revision is closely tied to critical reading; in order to revise a piece conceptually, students must be able to reflect on whether their message matches their writing goal.
Which activity is part of the revision process?
According to this, the activity that is expected to be part of the revision process is “adjusting details” because in the revision you improve your text by reading it and making positive changes.
What is the difference between minor and major revision?
Most commonly: “Minor Revision” implies that publication is desirable and a limited number of changes will bring the manuscript up to scratch. “Major Revision” implies that the manuscript needs considerable reworking prior to reconsideration.
What is the best thing to do during the revision stage?
Revision literally means to “see again” or to basically see something again from a fresh and critical perspective. One of the best things to do during the revision stage is to have someone else proof read the material for you.
What are the revision strategies?
- STEP ONE: THE BIG PICTURE. Look at the first draft in terms of larger, abstract qualities:
- STEP TWO: FOCUS ON DEVELOPMENT. does the main idea of the paper have enough supporting material?
- STEP THREE: FOCUS ON STRUCTURE.
- STEP FOUR: FOCUS ON SENTENCE STRUCTURE.
What are revision strategies for writing?
Creating a Revision Strategy
- When editing, tackle big changes (moving paragraphs, deleting sections, adding new material) before making small changes (grammar, spelling, citation formats).
- Many writers take multiple passes at a piece of writing, checking different aspects on each pass.
How can I improve my revision skills?
Revision means going over work in order to:
- Check your understanding.
- Make links between different topics to see how the whole subject fits together.
- Remind yourself of material you have forgotten.
- Reinforce your learning.
- Identify and fill gaps in your knowledge.
How long should a revise and resubmit take?
about 11 weeks
What are the benefits of revision?
In the revision process, you improve your reading skills and your analytical skills. You learn to challenge your own ideas, thus deepening and strengthening your argument. You learn to find the weaknesses in your writing.
What are major revisions?
Major revisions may require simply moving parts of the text around, or they may require the authors to reanalyze the data and rewrite the whole manuscript. Such revisions necessitate conceptual reorganization, proper judgment, and the investment of considerable time and serious effort by the author.
What are the steps in the revision process?
Upload your paper & get a free Expert Check
- Find your main point.
- Identify your readers and your purpose.
- Evaluate your evidence.
- Save only the good pieces.
- Tighten and clean up your language.
- Eliminate mistakes in grammar and usage.
- Switch from writer-centered to reader-centered.
How do you teach revision techniques?
Top Tips for Students
- Start your revision early.
- Make a revision timetable.
- Know what will be on each test.
- Know where your knowledge gaps are, so you can fill them.
- Turn notes into charts or diagrams.
- Discuss material with others and quiz each other.
What does Revision requested mean?
Manuscript Accepted or Revision Requested So, the journal has either accepted your manuscript or requested that you revise it for another round of peer review. In both cases, you should do exactly the same thing: revise your manuscript in accordance with the recommendations of the referees.
How long does a minor revision take?
about two-three weeks
What are the two levels of revision?
But to help us talk about revision, we’re going to distinguish three levels:
- Reseeing or rethinking: changing what a piece says, or its “bones”
- Reworking or reshaping: changing how a piece says it, or changing its.
- Copyediting or proofreading for mechanics and usage: checking for devia-
- Andrea Wanw,
How do you respond to a major revision?
Answer: You should always provide point-by-point responses to the reviewer comments in addition to incorporating the reviewers’ suggestions in your revised manuscript. What this means is that you will have to copy each of the reviewer comments into a word doc followed by your response to that specific comment.
What is revised paper?
What does it mean to revise? Revision literally means to “see again,” to look at something from a fresh, critical perspective. It is an ongoing process of rethinking the paper: reconsidering your arguments, reviewing your evidence, refining your purpose, reorganizing your presentation, reviving stale prose.
What is a major review?
A major review is an investigatory project that creates a business case for change. In some cases the purpose of the review is to develop and ensure the on-going integrity of an existing record or records.